DON’T WRITE WHAT YOU KNOW
Unfortunately, the writing world is full of so-called rules. Often they are attributed to famous authors, when they are nothing of the sort. For example, you can often see “J.K.Rowling’s Rules For Writing” appearing on the internet, even though she has flatly denied EVER talking about rules.
One of the great writing adages is: “write what you know.”
I can understand why people say that. As an author, you don’t want readers picking over your stories, telling you things that you’ve got factually incorrect. That’s not a good look.
Additionally, there is a danger of being accused of cultural appropriation, writing from the point of view of someone you don’t represent. Some clarification: you can write about characters and situations which don’t directly affect you, the writer; however, the writer should be careful when attempting to write from the point of view of someone who they don’t represent.
Here’s an anecdote: I’ve always tried to write inclusive characters in my stories. Characters who aren’t me. I love writing characters who have some of the same character traits as me, and readers will sometimes point to one of them and say “that’s you, isn’t it?”
I include many female characters in my stories. I’m not a female. So I don’t “know” what being female is like. This was brought into stark view when I started a psychological thriller – a woman in jeopardy story. I thought it was going well for the first couple of chapters, but then I offered it up for critique. And the feedback? “It didn’t work”, “I didn’t feel the jeopardy”, and worst of all “I could tell it was written by a man.”
Ouch.
And that, for me, is the clear distinction between writing about a character and writing as a character. That book has been shelved, by the way.
Now, having got all of that out of the way, what’s wrong with writing what you know?
If that rule was true, there would be no futuristic sci-fi. Nobody knows what’s going to happen ten, twenty, a hundred years hence.
If that rule was true, I’d always be writing about working class pensioners who spent a life in engineering, and have now retired.
If that rule was true, I’d always be writing cycling stories, stories about watching TV crime dramas, and stories about red wine.
So I’m going to offer up a different “rule”:
ONLY WRITE WHAT YOU UNDERSTAND